Morning Jew: Bridgegate, Chelsea Handler, last names & Bill Keller


As usual, Katie Halper and Heather Gold look at the week’s headlines and ask, “Was it good for the Jews?” This week, we tawk about the exciting origins of Ashkenazi Jewish last names (find out what YOUR name means, Jews. Or what your friends’ or enemies’ names mean, gentiles). Then we look at why New York Times’ Bill Keller feels the need to tell a woman with cancer to shut up and die the right way. Of course, we look at Bridgegate, which Heather thinks may actually be the best thing for Jews since sliced Challah. And then, we thank our generous tipper who wants to know our position on Chelsea Handler. Also, I Jew out Heather in a moment that supposed to end up on the cutting room floor.

And we’re on Zeek again!  Enjoy! You’re welcome!

Cops videotaped beating a man to death were just “doing their jobs” and acquitted

via LA Times
via LA Times

An attorney representing a policeman acquitted of  involuntary manslaughter on Monday said this: “These peace officers were doing their jobs…they did what they were trained to do”: beating a homeless man to death, as he screamed for help.

What was I thinking? I was so naive to even consider that the policemen caught on surveillance cameras beating Kelly Thomas to death in Fullerton California in the summer of 2011 would be held accountable. I lived through Rodney King and, of course, Amadou Diallo and Sean Bell and so many others. So, I should have known that these officers would be exonerated. Because, while Kelly Thomas was white, he was homeless and schizophrenic.

Police officers in Fullerton, CA were responding to reports about a man seen trying to break into cars near a bus depot on July 5, 2011. The police say Thomas, 37, fit the description and ran away after they found items belonging to someone else in his backpack. According to the police, Thomas resisted, so they called for backup and ultimately 6 officers were on the scene. The police say Thomas, who was unarmed and weighed 160 pounds was so strong and so resistant, that their force was necessary. But witnesses, medical reports and video say otherwise.

Witness Mark Turgeon recalled, ”They kept beating him and Tasering him. I could hear zapping, and he wasn’t even moving…. He had one arm in front of him like this, he wasn’t resisting. And they kept telling him, ‘He’s resisting, quit resisting,’ and he wasn’t resisting.” In a video of the incident one woman says, “They’ve Tased him five times already…. That’s enough!” Another witness says, “They’re freaking ruthless, I don’t know why they don’t just put cuffs on him and call it a night, instead of hitting him.”

Thomas can be heard screaming,  ‘I’m sorry,’ ‘I can’t breathe,’ ‘help,’ ‘Dad,’

One of the innocent cops, Jay Cicinelli, Tased Thomas four times, hit him eight times with the Taser and kneed him in the head twice. Another innocent cop Manuel Ramos snapped on plastic gloves, made two fists held them in front of Thomas’s face and  said, “Now see these fists? They’re going to fuck you up.” The prosecutor explained, ”Kelly Thomas was not responding when blows to his face occurred.”

The cause of death “compression of the thorax,” that made Thomas unable to breath. Medical records also show that Thomas’s had bones broken in his face, choked on his own blood and was stunned with multiple times with two Tasers.

When the paramedic arrived, he was told to attend to an officer with a minor injury. But the paramedic couldn’t help but notice Thomas as he lay in a pool of his own blood. Ron Thomas, Kelly’s father and a former sheriff, said,  ”Nobody at all from law enforcement directed them to Kelly. Kelly is dying in the gutter.” The paramedic had to clear Thomas’s nose and mouth of blood and his heart stopped on the way to the hospital. Kelly Thomas was removed from life support and died five days later.

Despite the overwhelming evidence, Ramos, 39, was acquitted of second-degree murder and involuntary manslaughter. Cicinelli, 41, was acquitted of involuntary manslaughter and excessive use of force.

Ramos’ attorney, John Barnett, actually said, out loud, the following: “These peace officers were doing their jobs…they did what they were trained to do.” Apparently, murdering unarmed people is just part of the job.

Not only does the Thomas family have to deal with the tragic murder of their son, but with the miscarriage of justice of the acquittal. Cathy Thomas, the victim’s mother, said ”I’m just horrified. They got away with murdering my son.” Kelly’s father told reporters, ”This is carte blanche to police officers to do whatever they want…. I’ve never seen such a miscarriage of justice… It’s so blatant. It means none of us are safe.”

The FBI is going to revisit the case, in light of the acquittal. But when will shocking police brutality stop being so un-shocking?

Former NYT editor mansplains to cancer patient to shut up and die the right way

817518279

Some journalists speak truth to power. But others, like former New York Times editor Bill Keller and the Guardian’s Emma Keller, write shaming and condescending advice to cancer patients.

Last Wednesday, Emma Keller decided to write about Lisa Adams, whose twitter bio reads, “Living w/stage 4 breast cancer. Writing about it at http://lisabadams.com . Mom to 3…. Doing as much as I can for as long as I can.” Well, for Keller, Adams is doing too much. In her op-ed “Forget funeral selfies. What are the ethics of tweeting a terminal illness?” (which provoked so much criticism the Guardian has removed it) Keller writes of Adams:

As her condition declined, her tweets amped up both in frequency and intensity. I couldn’t stop reading – I even set up a dedicated @adamslisa column in Tweetdeck – but I felt embarrassed at my voyeurism. Should there be boundaries in this kind of experience? Is there such a thing as TMI? Are her tweets a grim equivalent of deathbed selfies, one step further than funeral selfies? Why am I so obsessed?

Keller seems annoyed by the frequency of Adams’s tweeting: “Over the past few years she has tweeted more than 165,000 times (well over 200 tweets in the past 24 hours alone.)” At the same time, Keller is bothered that Adams is omitting crucial information: “She describes a fantastic set up at Sloan-Kettering, where she can order what she wants to eat at any time of day or night and get as much pain medication as she needs from a dedicated and compassionate ‘team’, but there is no mention of the cost.” I guess Lisa is guilty of too little information (TLI), as well.

Keller chastises Adams for expecting privacy, saying, in effect, if you didn’t want people you didn’t know to show up in your hospital room, you shouldn’t have written that tweet: “She was enraged a few days ago when a couple of people turned up to visit her unannounced. She’s living out loud online, but she wants her privacy in real life.” In case Adams missed Keller’s point, she reiterates it, addressing Lisa directly ”You can put a ‘no visitors sign’ on the door of your hospital room, but you welcome the world into your orbit and describe every last Fentanyl patch.”

Enter Bill Keller– former New York Times editor, current weekly columnist, and hubby/ knight in shining journalist armor of Emma Kelly– to the rescue. Bill decided to dedicate his column Monday to Lisa Adams as well. Speaking of TLI, Bill doesn’t even acknowledge that, coincidentally, his wife wrote about the very same woman less than a week ago, until the seventh paragraph! Bill condescendingly writes that, “Lisa Adams is still alive, still blogging, and insists she is not dying…” He contrasts Adams’s actions to the actions, or lack thereof, taken by his father-in-law:

In October 2012 I wrote about my father-in-law’s death from cancer in a British hospital. There, more routinely than in the United States, patients are offered the option of being unplugged from everything except pain killers and allowed to slip peacefully from life. His death seemed to me a humane and honorable alternative to the frantic medical trench warfare that often makes an expensive misery of death in America.

Translation: “Hey Lisa! Some of my best friends are My father-in-law had cancer, too! I mean, he was 79, and you’re not 40 yet and have a few young kids, but whatevs. Couldn’t you be more…unplugged? Couldn’t you die a more honorable death?”

Now there’s more. But if you’re mansplain-dar has already gone off, you’re not alone. Journalist Xeni Jardin, who has also tweeted about her breast cancer and says she was taken out of context by Emma Keller, tweeted that the Bill op-ed was:

…bizarrely tone-deaf, ghoulish, & lacking in empathy all at once. It mansplains breast cancer, but as if talking about a pork chop….Women w/metastatic disease are marginalized in the feelgood pinkwar. This oped reinforces that lack of respect for dignity, and bullies…it feels like a privileged man telling a woman in a hard place to just shut the fuck up and disappear.

Bill mansplains that Lisa doesn’t need to fight or take any “heroic measures”: “Among doctors here, there is a growing appreciation of palliative care that favors the quality of the remaining life rather than endless ‘heroic measures’ that may or may not prolong life but assure the final days are clamorous, tense and painful. (And they often leave survivors bankrupt.)…every cancer need not be Verdun, a war of attrition waged regardless of the cost or the casualties.”

And then, in words that must have Dylan Thomas convulsing in his grave, Bill says, “There is something enviable about going gently.” In case you missed the point, Bill ends his article by quoting another man who is critical of how Adams is treating her cancer: Steven Goodman, an associate dean of the Stanford University School of Medicine, makes the predictable disclaimer, “I’m the last person to second-guess what she did….I’m sure it has brought meaning, a deserved sense of accomplishment.” And then goes on to say, “But it shouldn’t be unduly praised.”

Bill would be wise to stop playing doctor, since he still hasn’t mastered journalism. As Adams pointed out,  ”If anyone even looked at my bio they would know I have three kids. Nice way to do research.” Speaking of shoddy journalism, as Greg Mitchell writes in The Nation, this “no fighting” advice comes “from the man who was a hawk on Iraq, staunchly defended Judy Miller and recently called for the bombing of Syria and backing the Al Qaeda rebels. ”

Unlike Bill, I’m not going to end my article by quoting a doctor who warns against praising Adams. I’m going to do what the Kellers, sadly, didn’t: let Lisa speak for herself and have the last word.

Screen Shot 2014-01-14 at 12.38.05 PM

Infographic of the Day: women, poverty & inequality

Picture 343

In a new investigative report, The Shriver Report: A Woman’s Nation Pushes Back from the Brink, the Center for American Progress and Maria Shriver look at the impact of poverty on women and the impact this poverty has on our economy, and society, in general. You can download the entire multi-media report (including the essay from Beyoncé that Maya cited yesterday) here until January 15th. And check out the “How Far We’ve Come and How Far We Need to Go“ infographic below the jump.

TSRweb-HowFar

Morning Jew

Katie Halper and Heather Gold look at the week’s headlines and ask, “Was it good for the Jews?” This week, we tawk

As always, we ask if these stories are good for the Jews. And we bring you a shandeh of the week. And we’re on Zeek again!  Enjoy!

Flashers, sexual violence, and racism: SNL’s new cast member, Sasheer Zamata, takes on serious issues

photo by Cate Hellman http://www.catehellman.com
photo by Cate Hellman http://www.catehellman.com

Joining the cast of Saturday Night LiveSasheer Zamata will become the first African-American woman to grace the show in six years. You mean there are actually funny people who are simultaneously female and African American? Who knew? (Not SNL, apparently.) It’s truly mind-blowing! Where did SNL find this person? Really, though, SNL got the memo that their lack of diversity–which Syreeta and Juliana have written about recently–was unacceptable and in no way a reflection of the lack of talent of people of color. Because there is no lack of talent among people of color; there is just lack of opportunity, thanks to places like…SNL, to come full circle.

Anyway, not only is Zamata hilarious, but she’s a smart cookie and talented writer and uses humor to tackle serious issues. Here are three videos that bring the funny to the… racist-capitalist-patriarchy.

1. “White White Ad Execs Make Commercials for Black People” is a video by UCB Comedy, which Zamata wrote and appears in. As you’ll see, it addresses white businesses’ attempts to capitalize on and commodify black people and exposes the racist homogenization and dumbing down of African Americans. Unlike my description, however, it’s funny and enjoyable.


2. Written by Zamata and made by UCB Comedy, “Be Blacker” takes on racism, and in–a life imitating art imitating life je ne sais quois–shows how white Hollywood either doesn’t cast black actors and, when it does, attempts to minstrelize them.


3. “Sasheer Meets Her Flasher” is a video directed by Chioke Nassor and written by Zamata. It looks at street harassment, flashers, sexual assault, masculinity and…”dicks.”


Fingers crossed, we’ll see a lot more of Zamata’s  biting social commentary and satire and a lot less of the white dude bro-ishness plaguing Saturday Night Live lately.

If anyone is able to add transcripts in the comments, I’d be very grateful it.

This is what the first African-American woman to sing at the Metropolitan Opera House sounds like

Originally published January 7, 2014 on Feministing.

On this day, 59 years ago, Marian Anderson became the first African American to sing at the Metropolitan Opera House in NYC.

Born in 1897 in Philadelphia, the contralto Marian Anderson broke through racial barriers and opened doors for countless African-American singers and performers. Being the first African-American person to perform at the Met would have been enough, but it was only one of her several achievements. Of course, Anderson’s fame and success–which included being the third highest concert box office draw in the U.S.–did not shield her from the horrors of Jim Crow and racism, and she was regularly barred from restaurants, hotels and performance venues.

In 1939, the Daughters of the American Revolution (DAR), an organization comprised of women who can prove their relatives took part in fighting for independence in 1776, barred Anderson from performing in Washington DC’s Constitution Hall, which they owned. As a result, then First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt rescinded her membership and helped organize a concert at another venue in the nation’s capitol. And on Easter Sunday, 1939, Marian Anderson sang on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, to a crowd of 75,000 people and millions of radio listeners.

The Daughters of The American Revolution would later invite Anderson to perform at their Constitution Hall. And then, because they are such suckers for tradition, they barred Hazel Scott, a pianist and the wife of Congressman Adam Clayton Powell (D-NY) from performing there.

Image via NPR

But back to January 7, 1955. On this day, Anderson would become not only the first African-American woman, but the first African-American person to perform at the celebrated Metropolitan Opera House in New York City. She appeared as a fortune teller in the Guiseppe Verdi opera Un ballo in maschera (A Masked Ball). Miles Kastendieck wrote a review of the performance in in N. Y. Journal American:

Marion Anderson’s debut on January 7 became one of the historic moments in the Metropolitan Opera’s 71-year-old story. For her it marked the realization of a childhood dream. For the Metropolitan it not only broke tradition but also set a precedent for including Negroes in future casts. For all it created an emotional occasion out of tribute to her as a singer and out of recognition that to her should fall this signal honor of opening the door for singers of her race…. Miss Anderson graced the stage through force of personality, dignity of stage presence, and vocal artistry…. An ovation had greeted her on the rise of the curtain…. The dark quality of her voice fitted the opening aria; so did its brilliance as it warmed into the rest of the scene.

Anderson recalled, “The curtain rose on the second scene and I was there on stage, mixing the witch’s brew. I trembled, and when the audience applauded and applauded before I could sing a note, I felt myself tightening into a knot.”

In addition to these feats, Anderson received the NAACP’s highest award, the Spingarn Medal, in 1938; the Presidential Medal of Freedom by President Lyndon Johnson in 1963; and honorary doctorates from more than two dozen universities. She sang at the presidential inaugurations of Dwight Eisenhower and John F. Kennedy. She was a delegate to the United Nations Human Rights Committee, and Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Anderson remained a champion of the Civil Rights Movement and sang, once again, at the Lincoln Monument for the March on Washington for Jobs and Justice.

Anderson died in 1993 at the age of 96.

Conservative media’s greatest misogynist hits of 2013: Feminism is a sexual perversion that causes statutory rape and more

screenshot of Fox segment on the American family


This year’s greatest misogynist hits from conservative media included gems like, ”You shut up. Know your role and shut your mouth,” the timeless assertion that feminism is “turning women into sexualized freaks,” and the classic claim that the victim was “manhandled” during “the so-called Steubenville Rape.” But there are so many more! Check them out after the jump.

In addition to the hits above, you’ll find doozies like:

  • An increase in female breadwinners is a “concerning and troubling statistic” by Lou Dobbs
  • Addressing sexual assault in the military “serves to objectify women, not as sexual objects but as weaklings who have no place in the military” by the Washington Times
  • Feminism “is based in what most people would classify as sexual perversion” by Rush Limbaugh
  • “the GOP… are such [insert euphemism of choice related to the female reproductive system]“ by Eric Erick Erickson

Check out the entire compilation at Media Matters.

Morning Jew looks at 2013: Was it good for the Jews?

In Jewish time for 2013, comics Katie Halper and Heather Gold take an absurd look at the year: Sheryl Sandburg, orthodox rabbis, marriage equality, Woody Allen, the Pope: what was good for the Jews? Who made the kvell and shonda of the year? What could be the best thing for the Jews in 2014?

We’re also happy to announce a partnership with Zeek a progressive Jewish site that will be showing morning Jew for the next while. This also means you’ll see morning Jew on the Forward. Our grandmothers would be kvelling.

10 Worst Sex and Relationship Tips From the Christian Right

These holy tips on love, dating and marriage will allow you to please yourself (not that way), your mate and your Lord.

We may have survived yet another war on Christmas. But we must remain vigilant. For the very same secularist, Muslim, homosexualist, communist, atheist freedom-haters who try to take the Christ out of Christmas (and put the melanin into Santa and Jesus) are attacking the very nexus of our entire 2,000-year-old (give or take) Earth: the relationship between man and wife. But have no fear. Below are some handy and holy tips on love, relationships, dating and marriage, which allow you to please yourself (not that way), your mate and your Lord.

1. Girls: shut up. Justin Lookadoo (how sexy is that name!) is a faith-based dating coach, motivational speaker and former juvenile probation officer (killer combo). His books include Dateable: Are You? Are They?The Dateable Rules and The Dirt on Sex. Lookadoo’s website offers the following gems:

  • “Dateable girls know how to shut up. They don’t monopolize the conversation. They don’t tell everyone everything about themselves.”
  • Shutting up also prevents girls from doing undateable things like asking boys out.
  • “God made guys as leaders. Dateable girls get that and let him do guy things, get a door, open a ketchup bottle [never thought of that one]. They… let guys be guys. Which means they don’t ask him out!!!!!”

Also, a dateable girl “isn’t Miss independent.”

2. Boys: be wild, but godly, and cover up your ladies. Lookadoo says dateable boys “bring God into it.” But that’s more fun than it sounds, since “men of God are wild, not domesticated. Dateable guys aren’t tamed.” But that doesn’t mean being too wild: God’s dateable guys know “porn is bad for the spirit and the mind. They keep women covered up.”

3. Share an eating disorder. The Christian Broadcast Network has some (101, to be exact) ideas for “Creative Dates.” A few of my favorites are nutrition-related: “Make up a fun diet together,” or “Eat creatively one whole day for $1.18.”

4. Engage in strange, antisocial and alienating behavior. Among the CBN’s date ideas are, why not “Kidnap a friend for breakfast … visit the library and ask the librarian a bizarre question … develop a new laugh together … survey the neighborhood with a self-made, bizarre questionnaire … go to the airport and watch people … run your own neighborhood day camp for one day.”

5. Pretend to be senior citizens. The 101 dating tips above are so fun you’ll probably run through them in no time. But don’t despair. Focus on the Family has even more great suggestions, including, “Date like you’re from the generation older or younger than you actually are. Eat ice cream cones and rollerblade in the park for a date fit for teenagers. If you prefer senior-style fun, eat applesauce, play bingo and watch a black-and-white movie.” While you’re at it, rock some Depends underwear, blast Fox News, and complain about having to keep up with the latest terms for black people.

6. Transcribe the Bible together. If you want to bring religion directly into your date, try out the following Focus on the Family idea: “Find a flat piece of scrap wood and use a permanent marker to write out your favorite Bible verses. Take it to a nearby beach, river or lake and toss it in the water. This may be of great encouragement to whoever finds it later on.” Fun for you, fun for your date, and totally creepy for the random person who finds it! What’s not to like?

7. Wives: keep the devil out by submitting. Karen Blake, the author of Do You Hear the Battle Cry? An Essential Handbook for the Wives of Christian Men, has a lot to say about marriage. The bad news is that, “Satan is out to kill your marriage and destroy your ministry.” (But we already knew that.) The good news is that “God has given you the tools to defeat him.” One of the best Satan-defeating tools is submission: “The devil has worked for centuries to set up a world system that says a strong woman must never submit to a man. It says, “Submission means getting walked on.” God clearly commands, “Wives, be subject—be submissive and adapt yourselves—to your own husbands” (Eph. 5:22, Amplified).” As usual, Michele Bachmann is right.

8. Put out so your husband behaves. In her Christian.com-published book No More Headaches: Enjoying Sex & Intimacy in Marriage, Julianna Slattery offers some great tips on how women can help their helpless husbands resist temptation. Take the story of Sheila and Mark:

“While Sheila seemed content to put their sexual relationship on hold for the time being, Mark responded by initiating more frequently. If he was a deer panting for water, she was a camel who seemed capable of walking through the desert for months at a time without a water break. [powerful imagery!]

Over time, Mark began to direct his sexual needs through masturbation and light pornography. A few nights a week, he would stay up late, surfing channels, hoping to catch a glimpse of something sexual. The guilt and shame he felt only intensified the rift of intimacy in their marriage…. More than anything else, he longed to be pure, to share his sexuality only with Sheila. But life was too busy, his desire too strong, his will too weak, and the gulf between them too great.

Like Mark, your husband depends on you to be his partner in his battle against sexual temptation…. you are a key component in his victory. You’re the only woman in the world whom your husband can look at sexually without compromising his integrity!”

9. Dump your Muslim girlfriend. Pat Robertson has much good advice for relationships. A Christian (duh) viewer of Pat Robertson’s 700 Club asked the holy host if he should marry his Muslim girlfriend of three years. Pat’s answer: “No way…. She wants to do her Muslim thing….Walk away.” Worried that walking out on a girlfriend isn’t the Christian thing to do? Don’t worry. It totally is. Robertson explains, Christ is “not gentle Jesus, meek and mild, he really isn’t.” Like so many men, Jesus Christ is merely misunderstood.

10. Stay married to your husband who sexually abuses your kids.In her surprisingly not very forward-thinking book, Created To Be His Help Meet: Discover How God Can Make Your Marriage Glorious, Debi Pearl literally tells women to stay with their abusive husbands:

“But if your husband has sexually molested the children, you should approach him with it. If he is truly repentant (not just exposed) and is willing to seek counseling, you may feel comfortable giving him an opportunity to prove himself…. Stick by him, but testify against him in court. Have him do about 10 to 20 years, and by the time he gets out, you will have raised the kids, and you can be waiting for him with open arms of forgiveness and restitution. Will this glorify God? Forever. You ask, “What if he doesn’t repent even then?” Then you will be rewarded in heaven equal to the martyrs, and God will have something to rub in the Devil’s face. God hates divorce — always, forever, regardless, without exception.”

God totally hates divorce. But he hearts abuse!